Is affiliate marketing a stepping stool to becoming a merchant?

I'm trying to understand something here. It seems that the main concerns with affiliate marketing is tracking, niches, cost of advertising, program leaks (such a phone numbers on merchant sites) - basically the lack of control after the visitor is passed onto the site you are referring them to.
So my question is, why not just become a merchant? I realize that there is extra work involved in becoming so, but I'm really trying hard to understand the differences. I was a merchant first before I got into affiliate marketing. When I compare the two, it seems to me that it takes the same amount of work in the long run. Sure, it might be a bit quicker to setup a one-page landing page with an affiliate link, but what are you trading off?
Let's examine a few facts just to make a fair comparison.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must incorporate in the long term to protect their business.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must have a bank account.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must budget for advertising and other expenses.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must build and market to a list.
- Both a merchant and affiliate can be sued.
- Both a merchant and affiliate want to own their customers.
- Both a merchant and affiliate eventually has to build more than just a one-page website to truly add value.
- Both a merchant and affiliate has to spend money to make money - or at least time.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must track everything.
- Both a merchant and affiliate should have access to a good attorney and accountant.
- Both a merchant and affiliate want as much control over their business.
- Both a merchant and affiliate want to automate as much of the work as possible.
- Both a merchant and affiliate can outsource most of the work.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must constantly learn and adapt to the marketplace.
- Both a merchant and affiliate have competition no matter what niche their in.
- Both a merchant and affiliate must constantly find new products/services to promote.
- Both a merchant and affiliate have many more similarities.
But then we get into the what I "think" in my personal opinion are the downsides of affiliate marketing.
- Unless an affiliate is capturing their visitor's info, they do not own the customer after they've passed them onto the merchant.
- They are only earning a smaller percentage of the sale while they may compete with merchants who have deeper pockets because of earning a higher margin. I consider any commission amount "smaller" since I tend to think long term. As an affiliate I may earn $1000 per sale, as an example, promoting a coaching program. Let's say I sell 30 and earn $30k. If the merchant is a master marketer, how much do you think the merchant will earn in the long term from those same 30 customers? How much do you think you will earn on the merchant's repeat sales if they don't offer recurring commissions?
- The liabilities, such as legal and financial liabilities, aren't really much different. Just because an affiliate is only "promoting" a merchant's offerings doesn't mean they can't be pulled into a lawsuit for any false or misleading claims they make about the product/service.
- Affiliates only get paid once for most affiliate programs available out there unless they pay recurring commissions on repeat customers. But even at that, some recurring programs expire after a certain period of time.
- Affiliates may have to wait weeks for their payouts.
- Unless an affiliate's site offers continuous value to visitors, there is not much reason for the same visitors to return to the site.
- Many more that I can list, but will save you the time. :)
When I listen to Jeremy and other top affiliate marketers, they tout how you must build a solid business plan. I totally agree. But once you get to their level where you're earning 6 figures or more, to me it becomes a toss up between being an affiliate or upgrading to a merchant. As merchant I don't have to worry so much about not getting paid by the merchant, AM's lying to me, leaving tracking up to someone else, how much money I'm going to lose long term from giving away the customer, having to compete with deeper pockets, etc.
Most may think that it takes longer to get setup as a merchant, but that's not necessarily true. It actually takes the same amount of time to setup a merchant account as it does a Paypal account. A business license is $25. A tax ID, just as an affiliate will need, takes 5-10 minutes on the IRS website. Setting up shop can take very little time depending on how extravagant you want to get. Take away design and you can be setup within a couple of hours with tens of thousands of products to sell. Maybe ten minutes to implement Google Analytics. Add another hour and have a couple dozen PPC ads setup. Before the end of the day maybe have some sales, customers for life (hypothetically), tracking stats, a small list, money in the bank within 24-48 hours, etc. You don't even have to give customers access to phone support and provide an F.A.Q. for their convenience. Have the products dropshipped. Outsource the fulfillment. Perform some backend marketing such as stuffing outgoing orders with flyers or samples of other products.
Just as a simple comparison - if I were to follow all of Jeremy's advice so far and instead find a source for the product and throw it up on Ebay as a merchant, I can have money in the bank - maybe even on on the same day deposited into Paypal. In addition, I don't even pay Ebay advertising fees until almost a month later. Going this route I don't have domain name expenses, web hosting, upfront PPC spending (outside of Google), etc.
As a merchant, when I hear an affiliate tout that they earned $100,000 in sales in just 3 days, my analytical mind starts to work the math. First, if you were the merchant, what would you have made in the same 3 days? $400,000 if you paid out 20%? $300,000 if you paid out 25%? Maybe $100,000 if you paid out an even 50%? Wrong, wrong, and wrong! You made out big time since the value isn't necessarily just in the upfront revenue. It's that and much more, such as list of buyers, the lifetime value per customer, the backend offers you may not payout on, the PPC expense your affiliates incurred for promoting your product/service/program and whatever else I may have forgot. I also then take the affiliate's $100,000 and divide that into 3-12 months to come up with some hypotheticals. Let's say the affiliate gets lax because of the big payout and doesn't do anything for the next 3-12 months. That means that the affiliate is earning $33,333- $8,333 per month on that one product or program since chances are, it's only hot in the beginning. Affiliates then have to look for the next "hot" deal to promote before those earnings dwindle even more.
If anyone has read the "The 4-Hour Work Week", Tim Ferris owned retail websites but outsourced just about everything. So if you're an affiliate thinking that becoming a merchant is just too much work - think again.
On the other hand, I do want to make several things clear. These are merely my "opinions" as I sit here today. I joined the Blank Ink Project and numerous other programs centered around affiliate marketing because I genuinely want to learn and maybe even convert over as a full-time affiliate marketer. My opinions of becoming a merchant are strong only because that's what I've been doing for over a decade. As an affiliate I've earned somewhere around the low four figures a year after expenses. If I worked a job and earned this kind of money on the side, it would be okay pocket change. But I imagine most everyone here would like to make a living full-time as an affiliate marketer.
I also don't have any hidden agendas here. I am not selling anything. I am not a coach. I don't have a membership site you can join or anything else. This is the first time I've come out of my box and posted my opinions in any public or private forums. I've even purchased Jeremy's PPC Classroom and recently signed up for Traffic University at $1000/mo. This is merely my initial quest for answers, so any productive comments, suggestions, and responses are welcome. As I learn more about the key differences of both, I'll be sure to share them with everyone.
Thanks in advance.
Cordially,
Jamie

Very thoughtful post. I
Very thoughtful post. I agree with many of your points. I think you summarized the benefits of being a merchant over an affiliate quite nicely.
Let me present a few (brief) counterpoints. I've always enjoyed playing devil's advocate ;)
As an affiliate there are three primary reasons I don't want to be a merchant:
1 - Customers
2 - Complexity
3 - People (vendors/contractors/employees/affiliates)
(Speaking from my own personal experience)
Like you, I have done both. I sold an e-book and a physical course. Both required more work, and were a lot more stressful.
Let's talk about some of the downsides of being a merchant (in no particular order):
- You have to manage people - even if you outsource everything, don't kid yourself into thinking that you won't have to manage contractors, vendors, affiliates etc. Everyone makes this sound easy, but believe me it can be like herding cats.
I've managed small teams (2-3 people) and big teams (80 people as a production manager). Finding good people you can trust is like finding a needle in a haystack. You have to go through a lot of turn over, training etc. to get this dialed in. I've read at least a dozen books on setting up virtual teams, etc. and none of them seem to address this adequately.
- You have to setup a business process Quick and reliable fulfillment, great customer service, and all of the other processes related to owning your own product don't happen magically. You have to put A LOT more planning and thought into it.
- You are more likely to be sued. As an affiliate your liability is extremely low. Lawyers will always go after merchants and networks before they come after you. You're the lowest man on the totem pole. For example, when the Florida Attorney General went after scammy ringtone affiliates who was his target? Affiliates? Nope. Merchants? Yes. Azoogle? Yes. He ended up getting a seven figure settlement out of Azoogle.
Was Azoogle at fault? No - not in my opinion. Sure maybe they could have done more to control their affiliates, but at the end of the day it was affiliates who misled consumers, not Azoogle. But it wasn't affiliates who paid the million dollar+ fine.
- You have customers. Not having to worry about customers is one of the biggest benefits of being an affiliate. Even if you outsource customer service (which is also a challenge) you will still have customer service issues escalated to you. As an affiliate I've never had to reply to a single e-mail, phone call, etc.
When I sold an e-book and physical course I was also a customer service manager. Download requests, password requests, fulfillment questions, general questions, etc.
We outsourced the customer service for PPC Classroom, which in my opinion was a bigger nightmare than just handling it ourselves. Missed replies, incorrect information, and the list goes on. This goes back to finding good people, but as you can see they're inter-related. As an affiliate these are both non-issues.
Selling your own book, course, or info product sounds attractive, but in my opinion it's not as attractive as being an affiliate. I've made 10x more money in affiliate marketing than I ever did selling products. I'm also 10x less stressed.
I've never talked about this publicly before, but I think now is the right time.
Quick Facts About PPC Classroom (merchant role)
Time Intensive
It took me 3 months to develop the product. I'm not talking about 3 months @ 40 hours/week. More like 3 months @ 80 hours /week (6 months) + several nights sleeping at the office. The week prior to launch I didn't see my wife and kids at all, and worked over 100 hours. I averaged about 2-4 hours of sleep a night (the week before, and the week after launch)
You'll note that a lot of this was self-imposed. We could have delayed launch, etc. But that doesn't mean less work.... it would have been the same amount of work spread over a longer period of time.
I also spent 3 months post-launch working full-time on the project.
Even if you produce a less ambitious product it's going to take you AT LEAST five times longer compared to developing an affiliate site for a comparable product.
Maybe after you have a few products under your belt this whole process becomes easier. I've launched 2 and neither one was easy.
Unforeseen Circumstances
- Production/fulfillment costs increased 100%, taking a huge bite out of our margins
- Denial of service (DOS) attack on launch day
- And about a dozen other little things...
Working with Vendors/Contractors/Etc.
- I already mentioned the increase in fulfillment costs
- A handful of shady affiliates that stuffed cookies and other fraudulent sales/transactions
- A few contractors dropped the ball, forcing us to change our game plan at the last minute. You can only imagine how stressful this was.
Customers
Let me preface this by saying - I love 99% of all PPC Classroom and QYDJ customers - (past/present/future). But that 1% of "unreasonable", "nothing will make me happy", "I expect the world for $", "I'm your customer and I own you" customers made my life a living hell. And even though it only represented 1% of customers, it was enough to make me never want to sell info products again.
We definitely made some mistakes, and made up for it whenever and wherever possible, but for some people it was never good enough.
Low Margins
After paying affiliates, vendors, contractors, partners, etc. I ended up walking away with less than a 20% cut of total revenue. Our affiliates made 50% of the sale, and didn't have any of this stress.
AN INTERESTING FACT:
I made more money on my affiliate campaigns during this same period of time, and spent less than 10% of my time on it.
For the record, this is not a post bashing PPC Classroom or it's partners, vendors, contractors etc. It's merely shedding some light on JUST A FEW of the challenges merchants face.
I had a lot of these same problems selling a simple e-book through ClickBank.
Will I Ever Sell Products Again?
I'm done selling "info products" in the business opportunity/internet marketing category. This was an important personal and business decision for me.
I haven't written off being a merchant. I'm still interested in developing software/web applications etc.
I've also considered writing/producing technical books/videos in a number of different categories. I've always felt I would make a good "INSERT for Dummies" author ;)
Now that I have two products under my belt I'm a lot more experienced and may avoid repeating some of the same mistakes thrice ;)
A Natural Progression (Affiliate to Merchant)
I don't necessarily think so... You can do one, the other, or both. All I can say is that if this is your first shot at doing an internet business, or you like to keep things simple - Affiliate Marketing is king ;)
My Two Cents
I have to agree with Jeremy.
I own and operate my own online dating site and I have a couple of affiliate dating sites. I easily spend ten times the number of hours on my own site dealing with customers, billing issues etc.
It's a headache and to be honest, I hate it. The only reason I keep it is because it's a money maker and having that extra security is nice.
Jeremy has told me time and time again to turn the site into an affiliate site and I agree with him 100%. Not only would the site be SO much easier to maintain but it would most likely make as much or more that what it's currently making and offer my visitors more value for their dollar. And I sure could use the extra time and money.
My affiliates sites are basically on autopilot and that is a HUGE plus.
Dan
Affiliate vs Merchants.
I would not want to be a merchant, I have done both, AM and been a merchant and being a merchant is a hassle. Dealing with customers, shipping, customer service, your own affiliates...etc. These are just some the things that are avoided through AM. Instead of focusing on those things I am free to build sites and market my campaigns, for which there is not enough time in the day as it is. Customers and customer service in general can be a true hassle, I am happy to pass customers onto to merchants, I don't want them and that is what affiliate marketing is all about.
Also with my own products comes the huge job of creation, development, testing, advertising...and all the other hassles that come with product development, including digital products as with Clickbank. With AM all that work has been done, the product is there, ready, tested, developed a brand name that is known, and this makes my job a dream.
Also there is virtually zero start up with AM, there are ways you could actually do AM without ANY start-up, as in Article Marketing, not so as a merchant. After all the costs are figured into the merchants campaign, the profit margins decrease, not so for Affiliates, with the low/no costs, the profit stays significantly more pure than it does for merchants.
Overall, affiliates make more money with a lot less hassle and costs than merchants. If you analyze a specific campaign from all the tiers involved it is almost always the affiliate that comes out on top. I can find a good niche, set up a site and launch within a few days, no way could I do that as a merchant.
As far as natural progression from affiliate to merchant, this is not a rule. Yes some affiliates become merchants, but affiliate marketing is NOT a stepping stone, it is a viable stable business in in of itself. A business that is thriving and generating millions+ in income even in the highly competitive, over saturated market that the Internet is today.
For me AM is the best all around!! I love being the middle man, I am happy to cash the checks while the merchant deals with all the hassles.
Olga
I'll give my $15,000,000 Worth
Gary Bracken
Yes, $15,000,000 is the approximate gross sales I generated running online hard goods businesses from 1997-2007...in fact, that's a very conservative estimate!
So why, you ask, is being affiliate marketer better than being a merchant?
Answer: I HATE the hard goods business and LOVE affiliate marketing...I can't say it any easier than that.
As a merchant, I was chained to my desk and home office most days of the year, waiting for UPS to either drop off or pickup packages bound for customers.
As an affiliate marketer, I can run my business on a wireless connection from a beach if I so desire, and can experiment with new markets on a whim, and my time commitment most days is usually about 2 hours. Not bad for the $72,000 profit I made last month (April 08)...there is nothing I am aware of that comes close to the freedom one experiences when running an affiliate marketing business that has been properly setup.
...but, to each his own I say!
Gary
My 2 Cents
Hello Jamie,
I can't throw around the figures of the other posts but I can tell you what I've seen and done over the years online. As a eBay powerseller I can tell you that the last thing you want to do is have your business model rely on eBay. Your continually at their mercy. There are many ways to have that biz go by-by overnight so I would suggest somewhere else for a presence as a merchant.
This is the reason I started looking into being an affiliate.
Also there are ways to do follow ups with certain kinds of affiliate programs if you capture emails before sending people to the merchant. I don't know for sure but I've heard aweber mentioned in one of the webinars and Jeremy might be getting to this later in the program.
And as you elude to being able to follow up is very important for repeat customers.
At the present time I'm doing both (merhcant/affiliate) and actually my merchant sells are keeping my online boat afloat as the affiliate starts paying for itself. Just the idea of not having to handle physical products is where I'm at right now.
Just my 2 cents.
Cheers,
Gary
Everything is a choice
Everything in life is a choice. That's what makes this country so great. We have the choice to do what we want. If being a merchant is more enjoyable, do it.
Some people think that AM will be easy. I don't. I want to do it because it's the new economy and I believe it involves a lot of analytical thinking. It's kind of like a chess match to see who can get traffic and make money. That's interesting to me and I want to challenge my brain. If you have a chance in life to do what you enjoy you're lucky!
To each his own!
chopper
I ran a design business
I ran a design business offline for 12 years and my business partner and I used to joke it would run a whole lot smoother without the customers, suppliers or staff.
I also ran a web design and hosting business for a few years and found that it was actually more demanding as the customers were all in different time zones so providing 24/7 support was somewhat challenging.
Due to these experiences and for the reasons stated above, I would never want to be a merchant. I'd rather live well and have few hassles than live very well and have many.
For my online affiliate business I have three rules:
1) Make money while you sleep
2) No employees
3) Never talk to customers
I had the "let someone else
I had the "let someone else do all the order fulfillment, customer service and product development" epiphany about a year ago. Affiliate marketing is the perfect business model for that to be a reality.
As far as I'm concerned Gary Bracken has the success story I'm reaching for!
"As an affiliate marketer, I can run my business on a wireless connection from a beach if I so desire, and can experiment with new markets on a whim, and my time commitment most days is usually about 2 hours. Not bad for the $72,000 profit I made last month (April 08)...there is nothing I am aware of that comes close to the freedom one experiences when running an affiliate marketing business that has been properly setup."
Thanks for sharing that Gary! I am working hard at getting "properly setup".
Jack Ball
Follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/JackBall - I'll follow you!
Gary Bracken
Gary Bracken
Thanks Jack...I feel like I'm still a beginner some days when I can't figure out what Google is doing to my campaigns, traffic issues, etc...
I will promise most of you this though, develop an attitude that you will succeed whatever it takes and however long you have to work at it...and you will have success, the hardest part is the time it can sometimes take to get your business going initially.
In the beginning I felt like I was on a roller coaster ride, making money one day and losing it the next...but I had 'burned my return ship home in the harbor' so to speak, as I didn't really have any job to fall back on to support my wife and two kids. The hard goods business I had run previously was not doing well (I was in $90K of debt from it in fact) and we were living off credit cards, and so i was desperate to succeed at affiliate marketing...some days that's all the kept me going...
I'm happy to help others succeed if I can (currently trying to get my brother going with AM), so if someone has any questions, please let me know...of course, I learned quite a bit from Jeremy's expertise in the industry...he's the man!
It took me approx 9 months before I started seeing nice profit margins on a consistent basis.
Gary
Are you on Twitter?
Gary,
Beside Jeremy the master, I'd like to learn as much as I can from other experts like yourself if I may. What is your twitter id so I could follow? In case you don't have then what is other way to stay in touch to possibly learn from you in the future? Thank you.
Gary Bracken Hey! My twitter
Gary Bracken
Hey!
My twitter name is MaximusPPC...But I've thought about changing that to MaximusPPL...
Here is my link:
http://twitter.com/maximusppc
Gary
These are some great responses guys! Keep them coming!
I do want to mention that I have sensed some similarities in most of the responses thus far and would like to point it out. Most of you who are or have been a merchant in the past describe the business as being yours alone. There were a lot of use of "I" as opposed to "we" when speaking about merchant experiences. I couldn't tell from the postings how big any of your companies were in terms of staff members to help out with all of the labor involved.
I tend to get the hint that maybe what affiliates seek most is to be independent. I myself can't say that I love or hate my customers since I don't ever hear from them. My call center and customer service reps handle almost all communications. I have a great warehouse team who handles shipping, ordering inventory, returns, etc. I hardly ever speak to vendors since my warehouse manager handles that for me. I don't manage our site since my web team in-house and overseas handles that. Our e-mail marketing, affiliate management, comparison shopping PPC management, in-house tech support is all outsourced. Our accounting firm now acts as our controller keeping our books.
I do want to mention that I do have several advantages over most. I owned a tech consulting company where we sold and fixed PC's, offered a variety of Internet services, web design, etc. I also went to school and majored under Computer Information Systems. This prior education and experience allowed me to handle most of the setup of our internal business systems in the early stages of our business.
However, I am a lot like like some of you. I sought to do everything myself such as answering phones, site maintenance, managing my affiliates, packing/shipping, marketing, vendor communications, customer service, etc. I also attained Ebay Power Seller status within the first few months. I did have my fiance's help along the way. But mind you - we both were young workaholics, perfectionists and control freaks. By our 3rd year we were raking in seven figure revenues, which was a lot of money for us being in our mid-twenties.
It took us about year or so before we sought help and even then, we only hired family to help out. At the peak of our early years there was me, my fiance, my mother and sister. But I still considered it to be "my" business even then. When my mother and sister moved on, I hired my fiance's brother and wife. That lasted about a year. Afterwards we both ran out of family members and almost gave up the business since we both didn't have any experience in management. It scared us to death to hire total strangers, and back then our business resided in our home. We thought about if for a while and decided to make a go at it. I'll be the first to admit that the next several years were bumpy when it came to finding good people. In 2007, we ended up outsourcing human resources. We also hired a business coach to train my fiance and I in management since we are acting directors in our company.
Today I can tell you that "we" did it as a company. We compensate our employees well. We teach them to manage themselves and the partner companies we work with. They're not totally independent yet, but they're getting close. Now "I" simply overlook the marketing, manage our SEO and PPC campaigns, and train my staff every once in a great while. Sometimes I don't even have contact with my staff but just a few minutes a week. My headaches nowadays have to do with the same stuff affiliates mess with, which is market research, strategy, marketing, educating myself, testing, tracking and analysis. I'm more of the idea generator while I hand off all of the work to others. Once I hand off the work, I have my staff overlook the quality of the work based on the standards set by me and the company. A good resource for what I am explaining here is Michael Gerber's "The E-Myth" series of books.
So what's my point? The point is, this certainly is hard work. However, over time you can get better at it as you discover little tricks you can institute. It's all a choice as chopper put it. It's also about compensation. I believe that most people have a price in where they will tolerate things that they hate if the price was right. To me, work is work. Eventually even if I were to become primarily an affiliate, at some point if I wanted to earn seven or even eight figures, I wouldn't be able to do it all by myself. So whether you avoid managing people, risks, and setting up business processes today - all of that will come into play in the future if your goal is to have time freedom and build a long-term, profitable affiliate business. As an affiliate you can only build so many websites, analyze stats, communicate with so many AM's, research a market, test, track, etc. Making money is simply a game of numbers. Find something that works and duplicate the heck out of it. You will only achieve a certain level of success if you try to do everything yourself whether you are a merchant or an affiliate. At some point you will want to hire out. It's simply a smarter way to work overall and long term. Someone has to know what it is you have setup just in case something happens to you and your family depended on the income of your business.
In regard to lawsuits, I've experienced first-hand where affiliates have been sued for millions for coming up with their own content that was NOT provided by the merchant. The merchant got sued along with them even though they had no knowledge that their products were being mis-represented in the marketplace. I hear about affiliates being slapped with trademark and/or copyright infringement all the time. Listen carefully to session 2 in Jeremy's program. Ultimately it comes down to how your business is setup, where it is setup, your level of risk taking, and little bit of luck. If your pocketing money either as a merchant or an affiliate, you can and may be held responsible for your actions. We got sued a couple of years ago for a product we sold. It was a frivolous lawsuit and we won - but it still ended up costing us tens of thousands of dollars protecting ourselves. Being incorporated doesn't necessarily mean that you are totally protected. A corporate veil may still be pierced and personal assets be gone after. Tip: Speak to an attorney and accountant about Nevada and Maryland corps. even if you do not reside in either one of those states.
Sorry for sounding like I'm pro-merchant. As hard as I try, that's just how it comes across for now. I'm hoping to change that by starting this journey with the newbies and pros. Only time will tell. Hopefully I can lend some of you some insight from a merchant's perspective that will help your affiliate business.
Thanks for the input thus far!
Jamie
Affiliate it is!
There is no way that being a merchant is easier than being an affiliate, even if you do have a team working for you and doing everything for you. We find it hard to believe that even if you did have a team in place to handle every aspect of the business, that you would have no worries.
Whenever you have a company that employs people and has direct customers, you are going to have problems that only the owner can deal with. Do you think that a CEO of a Fortune 500 company never has to make a decision? You can try and outsource as much as you possibly can, but you will always have something only you have to deal with.
Affiliate marketing is one of the only business models where you can make a very good living as a one-person operation and not have to deal with the end customer in any way, shape or form.
As a former merchant, affiliate marketing is hands-down the winner when it comes to a business model we choose to pursue. Being a merchant doesn't hold a candle to the potential of affiliate marketing.
Just our humble opinion...
Hi Jamie - it's good hearing
Hi Jamie - it's good hearing a merchant's perspective. You're 100% right about scale- an affiliate can only do so much by themselves. You will invariably hit a point where you can't grow your business any further without employees/contractors/help. I'm at that point right now.
Just a short time ago I had a goal of building an 8-figure business; it seemed like the next logical step. But then I read the 4 Hour Work Week and my perspective on building a big company totally changed.
I specifically recall the story of the Mexican Fisherman:
A boat docked in a tiny Mexican village. An American tourist complimented the Mexican fisherman on the quality of his catch. “How long did it take you to get those?” he asked.
“Not so long,” said the Mexican.
“Then why didn’t you stay out longer and catch more?” asked the American.
The Mexican explained that his small catch was quite enough to meet his needs and feed his family.
“So what do you do with the rest of your time?” asked the American.
“I sleep late, fish a little, play with my children, and take a siesta with my wife. In the evening, I go into the village to see my friends, have a few drinks, play the guitar and sing a few songs. I have a full life.”
The American interrupted. “I have an MBA from Harvard and I can help you! You should start by fishing longer every day. You can then sell the extra fish you catch. With the extra revenue, you can buy a bigger boat.”
“And after that?” asked the Mexican.
“With the extra money the bigger boat will bring, you can buy a second boat and then a third boat, and then more until you have an entire fleet of trawlers. Instead of selling your fish to a middle man, you can then negotiate directly with the processing plants. Pretty soon you could open your own plant. You could leave this little village and move to Mexico City, Los Angeles, or even New York! From there you could direct your whole enterprise.”
“How long would that take?” asked the Mexican.
“Twenty — perhaps twenty-five years,” replied the American.
“And after that?”
“Afterwards? Well, my friend,” laughed the American, “that’s when it gets really interesting. When your business gets really big, you can start selling stocks and make millions!”
“Millions? Really? And after that?” said the Mexican.
“After that you’ll be able to retire, live in a beautiful place near the coast, sleep late, play with your children, catch a few fish, take siestas with your wife and spend your evenings drinking and enjoying your friends.”
I think we all want to be the Mexican Fisherman, and that's why we love affiliate marketing ;)
The fisherman had the right idea
I am a small merchant, who has learned to service what I sell. I work the hours that I want, yet still bring in a good part-time income. But, I would like to be able to increase my income, without increasing the energy loss by the end of the day. I've always enjoyed physical exertion. But, I prefer the exercise regimen, where I can control the weight, instead of loading up the customer, regardless of how much the purchase happens to weigh.
I somewhat disagree.
LizWiz,
Sorry, but I somewhat disagree with your opinion. First, I never said that being a merchant is easier than being an affiliate. In fact, at the moment I feel that they're pretty even until I can better understand the key differences in how the affiliate model works.
A CEO of a dynamic and progressive company should not be making a lot of decisions. A CEO's job is to lead, inspire, motivate, set vision and standards for the company. My business only got so far when I tried to take control of every decision for my company. It's once I started draw upon my staff's input and ideas and allowed them to take ownership of some of their own decision making is when my business started to reach new heights.
For example, one of the techniques I use so that I don't ever have to deal with a customer is that I tell my customer service reps to deal with customer issues themselves if it takes less than $100 to resolve a situation. Since our average order size is $67, the last time I was bothered over a customer service problem was over a year ago! Plus, I have a customer service supervisor in place for them to go to if it needs to be escalated. It doesn't mean that I don't pay attention to my customers or don't care about upholding great customer service. It just means that I created a way to not have to deal with customers directly by empowering my staff to do so on behalf of myself and the company.
In addition, not every company has the owner acting also as the CEO. Just this year I started thinking about hiring a CEO for my company since I feel that I love sales and marketing more than I enjoy leading.
I can tell you with 100% certainty that one disadvantage of affiliate marketing is something you just mentioned. That is, not dealing with customers directly. Somehow, some way, you're going to have to find out what consumers want. You can use all the research tools and demographic services you want. But ultimately, if you can survey customers directly and ask them what they want, experience their buying habits for a particular niche first-hand, what makes them happy and what makes them turn a nose - you'll have a greater chance of converting them. You must always remember that you are always dealing with customers, whether direct or indirect. You may "think" you're not dealing with them by distancing yourself, but sooner or later you get pulled back into dealing with - people.
I've noticed a trend in the Internet Marketing industry lately. There has been quite a few top Internet Marketers who are going back to their roots to connect with their past customers. For example, I am Jeremy's customer since I paid for PPC Classroom. Although he may had not ever had to deal with me from a customer service perspective, he now has invited me into his coaching program for free. John Reese recently came out with a coaching program for just a few thousand dollars. All throughout he emphasized that he would help everyone as much as he can in order for them to be successful. There's a $10,000 seminar going on at the end of this month that I was invited to. While reading the sales letter, I noticed a comment they made about wanting to find new JV partners. I wrote the speakers back and told them that if it were important for them to find new partners, than why charge so much money? I asked them if they were afraid of scaring off some potentially great JV's from attending with the high price tag. I received an immediate reply back and was offered a 75% discount.
Don't get disillusioned and think that what you don't like are customers. It's people that you're ultimately trying to avoid. I'm an introvert and always have been. I tend to distance myself from people. But put me in a sales position and I can sell just about anything. Time is money and everyone is correct in implying that customers can take up a lot of your time. Well then, institute a way to where you don't have to deal with them. The truth is, "people" take up a lot of time.
You see, business is all about people. You can only hold them off for so long, but again, you can improve every situation. When we first started we did not offer a way for customers to call us. We simply did not post a phone number on our site. We made outgoing calls if there was a problem with the order, but overall, the phones were dead the majority of the time. We then posted our toll number and phone calls increased. Later, we acquired a toll free number and calls increased even more. After a while, we outsourced all of our sales calls to where my in-house staff only handled customer service. There were still quite a few service related calls. We then found out that the majority of the calls had to do with tracking their order, so we prominently placed a "Track Order" button on the top of our site. That immediately killed 50% of the incoming phone calls from day one.
Here's an interesting point about outsourcing our sales calls. We ended up finding out that our call center did not signup as many autoship customers as our in-house team did when they were taking the calls. So we brought the sales calls back into our facility during business hours and only use the call center after hours, the weekend, and overflow calls that come in if no one picks up during business hours after the 3rd ring.
My point is, I noticed that there are a lot of top affiliate marketers who once were fine staying underground. But now they are all coming out offering low cost or even free programs to re-connect with their customers. That's because ultimately, in my opinion, it's an invaluable opportunity when you can speak directly with your audience. Don't kid yourself. Even if you've built a large mailing list, as you should as an affiliate, you will invariably receive a few responses back from your list members each time you promote something to them. The question is - who is going to reply to them? You? An employee of yours? Or one of your VA's from India?
Business in general is hard work. You may be right that being a merchant is much more involving than being an affiliate, but that depends on who you're talking to. If I told you that we did $5 million our 3rd year in business with only 3 of us working it, would you at least be interested in finding out how? If your answer is no, than you're probably better off working for someone else. The reality is - people will gravitate towards a way of making money that works for them. As much as I would love to generate $5 million as an affiliate, I'm not yet sure if "I" can until I try it for myself. Sometimes the "easier" something is to get into, the "easier" it is to fail in it. In one of the network marketing companies I'm joined up with, it costs only $40 to become a distributor. In a short time, I was earning an amount double of what most people take home in a year. But although hundreds signed up for the same money making opportunity, they were in and out of it just as fast as they filled out the distributor application.
I find that being a merchant keeps you disciplined since you have a lot more at stake. A few years ago I trained a group of 8 people who were close to me how to make money direct-linking Google Adwords ads simply using affiliate links as the destination url. About 3 out of 8 of those people were consistent enough in creating enough ads to generate a $400-$600 a month consistently. This went on for about 6 months until all of them just straight out quit altogether. They left their ads up, but ceased creating new ads. To this day, they are all still working the same jobs they did when they started. Figure that one out.
Going back to affiliate marketing, my ultimate goal is that Jeremy and others can show me how to exceed what I am earning with less overall time involved. I don't even so much care if the work is harder, just as long as I can spend less time in the business and generate more revenue.
Wow
Gary Bracken
Wow! In the time that it took you to write that reply above I launched 2 new affiliate offers!
:-)
Gary
I understand what you're saying
I was a lead man/supervisor for what was (past tense) the largest custom furniture manufacturers in the U. S. The only one in the company who was getting raises for the last year of their existense. But, I found out that it is better when I am making my own decisions. I have the talent, and the abilities to run the other mans company. But, the other man may not have the talent, or ability to keep his company solvent. I therefore choose to use my talents to earn my income independant of the other man. Just my opinion.
Yep Brack, that's exactly my
Yep Brack, that's exactly my point. It's not so much customers that take up everyone's time, it's people in general. No use joining a community if you're not willing to to put some time into some discussions...
I can tell you from
I can tell you from experience that being a merchant involves a lot more responsibility. I used to own an e-commerce website and had to deal with phone calls from customers, chargebacks, damaged goods, keeping products stocked, vendors etc.
This of course is from my own experience selling physical goods. I'm not sure how it would be if I sold downloadable information products but I would guess that'd be the way to go if you want to become a merchant.
Putting Systems in Place
Congratulations to Jamie, Jeremy, and Gary for all running such successful businesses, whether it be as a merchant or an affiliate marketer. Obviously, both kinds of business takes smarts and motivation to do well. Another common factor seems to be creating and maintaining good systems to operate their businesses, manage their growth, and turning them into "cash cows".
I'm currently a merchant with a small staff and a wholesale business that is reasonably successful. However, I built that business without the systems in place that would allow me to run it with much less effort and more renumeration than I do now.
While I could restructure my "hard goods" company to have better systems and eventually provide more of the flexibility I want, that would be a form of "reinventing the wheel". So instead, I'm looking to start an AM business from scratch, putting good systems in place from the beginning, and eventually "quit my day job" (even if I own the company).
Good luck (and success) to us all!
Abigail